RE: Clinton on Yucca Mtn.

[Jack_Earley@RL.GOV]

"He hasn't seen scientific evidence. . . ." 



Doesn't matter--he wouldn't remember it if he had.



Jack Earley

Radiological Engineer





-----Original Message-----

From: Jim Hardeman [mailto:Jim_Hardeman@MAIL.DNR.STATE.GA.US]

Sent: Wednesday, May 01, 2002 3:46 PM

To: radsafe@list.vanderbilt.edu

Subject: Clinton on Yucca Mtn.





Colleagues —



Not that anybody cares what a former President of the United States thinks,

but take a look at the following articles which appeared in the Las Vegas

Sun over the past few days ...



URL =

http://www.lasvegassun.com/sunbin/stories/archives/2002/apr/29/042910641.htm

l



URL =

http://www.lasvegassun.com/sunbin/stories/archives/2002/apr/30/513381596.htm

l



Jim Hardeman

Jim_Hardeman@mail.dnr.state.ga.us 



===========================================



April 29, 2002 



Clinton tells Las Vegas crowd that Yucca Mountain not justified



LAS VEGAS (AP) - Former President Bill Clinton told a packed crowd at UNLV's

Thomas and Mack Center on Monday that he hasn't seen scientific evidence

that Yucca Mountain is safe to store the nation's nuclear waste. 



"I think it's a mistake," he said, referring to the recommendation by

President Bush to make the proposed site 90 miles northwest of Las Vegas a

national nuclear waste repository. 



The two-term Democratic president said during a question-and-answer session

following his 35-minute guest lecture that he disagrees with the position

the Bush administration has taken on Yucca Mountain because "the science

doesn't justify this." 



He added that he never promised Nevada that he would not approve Yucca

Mountain as the repository for 77,000 tons of spent nuclear fuel and other

highly radioactive wastes, but Clinton stressed that the decision would have

been based on sound science. 



Both chambers of Congress soon will vote on whether to override Gov. Kenny

Guinn's veto of Bush's recommendation. Nevada officials have acknowledged

they will lose big in the House, and are focusing on trying to muster a

majority in the Senate. 



Majorities in the House and Senate must override the governor's veto for the

Yucca site to become final and for the Energy Department to begin preparing

a repository license application. 



Clinton advised Nevada residents to continue to educate members of the

Senate, especially those representing small states. 



"Ask them if they would want this in their state," he said. "Don't give up,

just keep making the case." 



Bush and Congress are under the gun to come up with a solution about what to

do with the spent nuclear waste being stored at facilities around the

nation, many of which are near largely populated areas, Clinton said. 



"They're under enormous amounts of pressure to just do this and get it over

with, so they're going to dump it on you," he said. "I don't think that's

right." 



Clinton added that allowing the highly radioactive waste to be buried would

prevent the government from being forced to fund studies on how it could be

neutralized instead. 



Demand for tickets to Clinton's talk, presented as part of the Barbara

Greenspun Lecture Series, was so high that the event was moved from the

3,100-seat Cox Pavilion to the arena. 



All 6,500 free tickets were distributed, university officials said. 



===========================================



April 30, 2002 



Clinton applauds Yucca fight



Ex-president says Nevada should lobby small-state senators

By Erin Neff 

<erin@lasvegassun.com>

LAS VEGAS SUN



Bill Clinton said Monday if he were still the president of the United

States, he would not approve Yucca Mountain as the nation's nuclear waste

repository until unanswered scientific questions were solved.



But after a speech to about 6,000 residents, politicians and students at

UNLV as part of the Barbara Greenspun Lecture Series, Clinton stressed that

he never opposed the site outright.



"I never promised Nevada that I wouldn't approve the site," Clinton said in

response to a question submitted in advance by a UNLV environmental studies

student. "The only promise I ever made to you was I wouldn't do it if I

weren't convinced it was safe based on the science."



Two independent panels have determined that almost 300 scientific questions

must be answered before Yucca Mountain could be licensed to hold waste.

During his presidency, Clinton vetoed a proposal to temporarily store waste

at Yucca Mountain.



Clinton's five-minute response to the Yucca Mountain question came after a

35-minute speech on America's role in a global community -- a role he said

had greater relevance in the post-Sept. 11 world.



But his Yucca statements drew the most laughter and hearty applause of the

night.



Clinton discussed the legislation placing Yucca on a list of three potential

places, including Deaf Smith County, Texas, in western Texas, "which is

farther from any large population site than this one here," he said to

tremendous applause.



Clinton then said he read an article that said the original transportation

route was changed when it took the waste within 100 yards of the U.S.

Capitol.



The Energy Department has not published any transportation routes.



Still, Clinton's comment on the routes drew laughter. "They had to reroute

it," Clinton said. "If the think it's so darn safe why don't they leave it

where it is?"



The laughs led him to comment that the whole situation is laughable due to

its absurdity.



"Oh, I don't want it in Texas," he said, hamming to the crowd by taking a

jab at the way leaders in Washington are deciding the issue. "And I don't

want it traveling too close to the Capitol. And I'm sorry you had an

earthquake on the site. I really am. But we've got to put it somewhere, and

I'm just going to ram it through to Nevada."



Clinton recommended that Nevada take its case to the senators of every small

state and "ask them how they would feel if this was being done to them."



He also said he was sympathetic to utility companies that are trying to

remove the waste so they can generate more power. But, he stressed, the

current solution is being promoted "in a superficial way."



"I just think it's a mistake. I don't think it can be justified on the

merits," Clinton said.



After spending about 40 minutes answering questions, Clinton worked the

crowd, signing autographs, posing for pictures with babies and shaking

hands.



"I touched him," screamed Marcia Gomez, a nurse at University Medical Center

who said she was thrilled to meet one of her personal heroes.



"I love him for all the things he talked about," said Gomez, who is black

and who noted Clinton's commitment to racial equality.



During his speech -- interrupted 18 times by applause -- Clinton appeared

most troubled when discussing the current battles between Israelis and

Palestinians in the Middle East.



He said both sides are trapped in a "death lock" over what individual

residents want and what their countrymen believe en masse. As a result,

Clinton said, America must stay involved -- perhaps by sending in troops --

to validate the peace efforts.



Clinton also applauded the recent trip to the region by Secretary of State

Colin Powell, saying he disagreed with preliminary reports calling his visit

a failure.



"We have to start with the little steps," Clinton said.



He also talked briefly about his current life as Citizen Clinton -- a public

servant who splits his time between speeches, fund-raisers, writing,

planning his presidential library and promoting his foundation.



Clinton has given almost 200 speeches in 30 countries since leaving office,

according to a recent article in Newsweek. The overseas speeches earn him

between $200,000 and $300,000, with talks to American conferences and

banquet appearances beginning at $125,000. Organizers declined to discuss

the speaking fee.



Monday's speech, sponsored by the Greenspun family, which owns the Sun, was

offered free. The lecture series, which has featured Carl Bernstein, Leslie

Stahl and Hillary Clinton in recent years, is typically held in the

1,800-seat Ham Hall at UNLV.



But organizers knew Clinton could pack the 3,500-seat Cox Pavilion. When

tickets quickly ran out for that venue, the event was moved to the Thomas &

Mack Center -- with curtains blocking out more than half of the arena to

give the speech a more intimate feel. A total of 6,500 tickets were

distributed, with numerous state and local politicians grabbing VIP seats on

the floor, and the public filling the general admission seats in the stands.



The majority of those in attendance Monday cheered wildly when Clinton took

the stage and stood when he concluded his speech.



Although the former president was dogged by sexual scandals and impeachment,

many in the crowd said they would vote for Clinton again if they could.



"He's the best president we'll ever have," said Corey Russell, who snapped a

photo of his 6-month-old daughter, Carter, with Clinton.



Jessica Yatrofsky, a 20-year-old UNLV sophomore, said she found Clinton's

remarks refreshingly honest.



"He didn't talk around the questions," she said. "He just came out and told

it like it is. It's not the kind of vibe that I get from President Bush." 













************************************************************************

You are currently subscribed to the Radsafe mailing list. To unsubscribe,

send an e-mail to Majordomo@list.vanderbilt.edu  Put the text "unsubscribe

radsafe" (no quote marks) in the body of the e-mail, with no subject line.

You can view the Radsafe archives at http://www.vanderbilt.edu/radsafe/

************************************************************************

You are currently subscribed to the Radsafe mailing list. To unsubscribe,

send an e-mail to Majordomo@list.vanderbilt.edu  Put the text "unsubscribe

radsafe" (no quote marks) in the body of the e-mail, with no subject line.

You can view the Radsafe archives at http://www.vanderbilt.edu/radsafe/