[ RadSafe ] DEATH TOLLS THAT DON'T MAKE MANY HEADLINES

[Maury Siskel]

9 SEP 05 Notebook by Mick Hume

We can't eliminate all risk, but we could cut out the doom-mongering

THE OFFICIAL DEATH toll is 56, and the final body count is set to be 
many times lower than the hysterical estimates of tens of thousands of 
deaths. This is the good news that you probably missed, hidden away 
among the apocalyptic headlines from New Orleans. It comes from a UN 
report, published this week, into the nuclear accident at Chernobyl in 
1986 — the disaster that we were warned would spread cancers, 
infertility and two-headed sheep from the former Soviet Union to the 
Lake District.

Talking about death tolls that do not make many headlines, how many 
people have died from vCJD — “the human version of ‘mad cow’ disease” — 
in the UK so far this year? The answer is: two. This brings the number 
of deaths since the BSE-vCJD panic took off in the mid-1990s to 150. I 
am no statistician, but 150 deaths seem some way short of the up to half 
a million that leading authorities predicted.

[Note: consider also for how many decades Africa has been destroyed by 
AIDS -- Maury]

There is a lesson here about the way that we view man-made and natural 
disasters. For years, Chernobyl and BSE-vCJD have been held up as proof 
that our future is threatened by new risks that result from humanity’s 
scientific and technological advances, such nuclear power and modern 
farming techniques.

Ulrich Beck, the sociology professor whose work on “the risk society” 
influenced new Labour, declared that Chernobyl demonstrated “the failure 
of techno-scientific rationality in the face of growing risks and 
threats from civilisation”. During the “mad cow” panic, John Gray, the 
British philosopher, blamed our “culture of technological mastery of 
nature” for creating “incalculable but catastrophic risks”, and 
suggested that a significant CJD outbreak could be seen as “a symptom of 
nature’s rebellion against human hubris”. Notions about the dangers of 
hubris (what we used to call progress) have since become mainstream, in 
the backlash against everything from GM crops to the MMR vaccination.

Recent events should remind us, however, that reality does not always 
follow the doom-mongers’ script. The dramatic dangers to life and health 
today are less new-fangled “risks and threats from civilisation” than 
old-fashioned risks and threats from hurricanes, tsunamis and diseases. 
Far from being the problem, the advance of human ingenuity, technology 
and civilisation offers us the best chance of protection.

We cannot, and should not try to, eliminate all risk from life. But we 
would do well to cut out the doom-mongering. The UN report on Chernobyl 
concludes that people in the region have been affected less by radiation 
exposure than by exposure to overblown fears about it, which has left 
them suffering from “paralysing fatalism”. That almost sounds like a 
fate worse than death.

NEW ORLEANS has long been popular with tourists keen for a safe taste of 
the seamier side of American life. For the past fortnight it seems that 
the ghost town has played host to another breed of voyeuristic tourists 
— television crews searching for the most garish snapshot of “America’s 
underbelly”.

As if the news were not bad enough, it has often been made to seem worse 
by a type of reporting for which no horror story can ever be too 
horrific. What began as the grim story of a natural disaster soon became 
a grimmer moral tale of man’s inhumanity to man and woman. Too much of 
the media have resembled an international outlet for the sort of rumours 
that always spread like wildfire in disaster zones, reporting riots, 
rapes and murders (including of children) inside the Superdome as if 
they were established facts. Yet all we knew for certain was that 
conditions were terrible. By the middle of this week a New Orleans 
police superintendent was still making clear: “We don’t have any 
substantiated rapes.” No rape victims, murder victims’ relatives or 
witnesses had emerged. By then, however, the media had moved on to the 
alleged threat of cholera and typhoid.

With some of these TV reporters, you get the feeling that their ideal 
story would be to report “live” from just outside Dante’s seventh circle 
of Hell, while speculating on whether a government cover-up is hiding 
the existence of an eighth circle. Jon Snow, who heroically presented 
Channel 4 News from New Orleans in his wellies, tells us in his 
self-effacing way: “To be a hack caught up in this is tough.” Couldn’t 
somebody have airlifted them out of there sooner?

Mick.Hume at spiked-online.com