[ RadSafe ] More radiation, less heart disease (much of total) NSWS
hflong at pacbell.net
Tue Mar 18 18:41:31 CDT 2008
"The ubiquitous nature of the radiation response in cellular, animal and epidemiological studies
negates the healthy worker effect as an explanation for hormesis." BScott at lrri.org
----- Original Message ----
From: John Jacobus <crispy_bird at yahoo.com>
To: howard long <hflong at pacbell.net>; John R Johnson <idias at interchange.ubc.ca>; Fred Dawson <fred-dawson at blueyonder.co.uk>; srp-uk at yahoogroups.com
Cc: radsafe at radlab.nl
Sent: Monday, March 17, 2008 3:05:36 PM
Subject: Re: radiation and heart disease link - prevention!
I am not the one who originally questioned this study. The fact that the unexposed workers had a higher cancer rate than the general population brings into question the validity of the study beyond the intent. I can, and have, provided you with copies of the analysis of the study. Unfortunately, your beliefs do not change the facts that this is not a reliable reference.
The fact that the workers "appear" to be healthier does not translate into lower risk of heart disease. As a physician, I assume that you know that heart disease is not the only cause of death. Your conjecture that the study " MUST have included reduction in heart disease" is clearly without proof or merit beyond your own spectulation.
Dr. Cameron was a well recognized physicist who gave much to the medical physics community. Nevertheless, he was no epidemiologist.
Again, if you wish to continue this discussion with me, please do so off-list. We need to respect the wishes of those who do not what to again be bothered with this issue.
howard long <hflong at pacbell.net> wrote:
Your persistent denigration of Cameron's work
does require correction to all Radsafe.
NSWS revelation of amazing reduction in total mortality
(0.76 expected vs controls that eliminated healthy worker effect)
when >0.5 rem accumulated addition, MUST have included
reduction in heart disease (over 30% of total mortality).
This small addition of 0.5 rem (rad, cSv etc) is less than
a whole body scan and about what I get from
sitting on thoriated welding rods 3 hours a day, and
even more convenient than my sunbathing an hour a week
for another healthful radiation supplement.
I have a cc of Cameron's analysis for all who e-mail for it.
There was no more healthy worker effect than in the controls.
Thank you for keeping HPs aware.
More information about the RadSafe