[ RadSafe ] OT: RE: Rational Thought -- Wind Power
cary.renquist at ezag.com
Tue Oct 4 17:05:23 CDT 2011
I hate to jump in on threads like this, but I just read something
yesterday that seems relevant.
There may be a bigger setback if wind generation is treated like the
The U.S. Attorney for North Dakota hauled seven oil and natural
gas companies into federal court for killing 28 migratory birds
that were found dead near oil waste lagoons. The Class B
carry fines of up to $15,000 for each dead bird and up to six months
You may not be surprised to learn that the Administration isn't
prosecuting wind companies for similar offenses.
The wind industry each year kills not 28 birds, or even a few
but some 440,000, according to estimates by the American Bird
based on Fish and Wildlife Service data.
It sounds like legislation will soon be passed that will absolve the
wind industry from responsibility for migratory bird deaths.
cary.renquist at ezag.com
From: radsafe-bounces at health.phys.iit.edu
[mailto:radsafe-bounces at health.phys.iit.edu] On Behalf Of Brennan, Mike
Sent: Tuesday, 04 October 2011 14:34
To: The International Radiation Protection (Health Physics) MailingList
Subject: Re: [ RadSafe ] Rational Thought
If you stop saying things like, "Since the wind energy is free..." you
would enhance your credibility on a number of subjects. I actually like
wind power, but it is far from free. The installation costs are high
and will increase, as it becomes more apparent that huge wind turbines
are another NIMBY issue. This is will become even worse as the best
locations are used, and more marginal locations are left. Wind turbines
actually take a substantial amount of maintenance, as the machinery is
pretty close to as good as we can currently build. The decommissioning
costs will be high (what, you thought they would last forever?),
especially if someone decides for non-technical reasons that the
material can't be recycled (as it clearly should be, just as spent
nuclear fuel should be). There are already people who live within miles
of wind turbines who claim the noise and/or electrical fields are
damaging their health and making the cows act funny. I live in
confidence that someone who is against wind turbines will be able to
find a cluster of something that can be blamed on them; maybe even
showing that the turbans are so dangerous that the health effects reach
back through time.
And that's not counting the cost of milling birds and bats, a technical
issue that has been dealt with by deciding not to think about it,
As Dixie Lee Ray said, "There is no such thing as a free lunch. Behind
every little bundle of love is a pile of dirty diapers." Industrialists
and environmentalists alike hated her for saying things like that, but
that didn't make her wrong.
More information about the RadSafe