[ RadSafe ] Fwd: Invalid Claims Made for “What Happens to Your Brain on the Way to Mars” Publication
Brennan, Mike (DOH)
Mike.Brennan at DOH.WA.GOV
Mon May 4 17:40:22 CDT 2015
This is kind of like simulating the annual snow/hail fall on a particular location with a block of ice of a similar mass, dropped from cloud height, and concluding that everyone in New England and the Midwest dies each year.
From: radsafe-bounces at health.phys.iit.edu [mailto:radsafe-bounces at health.phys.iit.edu] On Behalf Of David Hunter - Hunter Geophysics
Sent: Monday, May 04, 2015 3:30 PM
To: The International Radiation Protection Mailing List
Subject: [ RadSafe ] Fwd: Invalid Claims Made for “What Happens to Your Brain on the Way to Mars” Publication
The below email may be of interest to RadSafe members. It concerns the effect of radiation on astronauts travelling to Mars.
Dave The Grave Hunter
Director - Hunter Geophysics
Specialists in the geophysical detection of unmarked graves.
Office: 03 9913 2259
Mob.: 0488 501 261
Secretary, Treasurer & Webmaster
La Trobe University Archaeological Society www.latrobearchsoc.org
> Begin forwarded message:
> From: The Mars Society <info at marssociety.org>
> Subject: Invalid Claims Made for “What Happens to Your Brain on the
> Way to Mars” Publication
> Date: 5 May 2015 8:22:40 am AEST
> To: <david.hunter at huntergeophysics.com>
> Reply-To: The Mars Society <info at marssociety.org>
> MARS SOCIETY ANNOUNCEMENT
> View this email in your browser
> Invalid Claims Made for “What Happens to Your Brain on the Way to
> Mars” Publication By Dr. Robert Zubrin, President, The Mars Society
> May 4, 2015
> In a paper entitled “What happens to your brain on the way to Mars” published on May 2nd in the open-access journal Science Advances <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage2.com/track/click?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=188340a9f4&e=b79b1e1ff5>, a group of radiation researchers claimed that their recent work causing memory loss to mice by administering very large doses of galactic cosmic ray (GCR)-like high energy radiation has serious implications for human Mars exploration. According to the authors <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage.com/track/click?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=2cccd2146a&e=b79b1e1ff5>, similar effects might severely impact astronauts going to the Red Planet, thereby placing the feasibility of such enterprises in serious question.
> In fact, however, the study has no relevance for human Mars exploration, as the irradiation doses inflicted on the researchers’ unfortunate subjects has no relationship to what would be experienced by astronauts on their way to Mars. The principle difference is that the rate that the dose was administered to the mice under study was 4 million times faster than that which would be dealt to travelers in interplanetary space. In addition, the total cumulative dose delivered to the mice inside of 30 seconds was about 50% greater than the GCR dose that astronauts would receive over the course of a 2.5 year Mars mission.
> The key numbers in question are as follows: In the mouse experiment,
> the victims were given a dose of 30 rads (0.3 Gray) at a rate of 100
> rads per minute. On a Mars mission, astronauts would receive a dose of
> 1 rad per month during the 6 month outbound and return transfers, and
> about 0.5 rad per month during 18 months on Mars, for a total of 21
> Rads. ( 1 Gray = 100 rads = 100 cGray. For GCR 1 Gray =6 Sieverts =
> 600 rem. Space dose rates can be found in “The Cosmic Ray Radiation
> Dose in Interplanetary Space – Present Day and Worst-Case Evaluations
> bc3a161cc0&id=704a46cddb&e=b79b1e1ff5>” R.A. Mewaldt, et al, 2005.)
> The 4-million-fold difference in dose rate between the “What happens
> to your brain on the way to Mars” lab study and spaceflight is of
> critical importance. It is a well-known finding of both chemical and
> radiation toxicology that the effects of large doses of toxins
> delivered suddenly is entirely different from the effect of the same
> amount of toxin delivered in very small amounts over a long period of
> time. The difference is that the body’s self-repair systems cannot
> deal with a sudden dose that they can easily manage if received over
> an extended period. For example, if an individual were to drink one
> shot of vodka per second for 100 seconds, he would die. But if the
> same person drank one shot of vodka a month for 100 months, he would
> experience no ill effects at all. This is about the same ratio of dose
> rates as that which separates the invalid work reported in the “What
> happens to your brain on the way to Mars” paper (1.6 rad per second)
> from that which would be experienced by astronauts in space (1 rad per
> It is shocking that the “What happens to your brain on the way to Mars” authors neglected to caveat the significance of their results by admitting these differences. Not only that, they kept the information about actual dose rates employed buried deep within the paper (it can be found in the middle of a text paragraph towards the end entitled “Animals, heavy ion radiation, and tissue harvesting), thereby allowing it to easily be missed by popular science writers duped into reporting the allegedly sensational implications of their irrelevant work.
> It is true that small amounts of toxins received over a long period can statistically increase a person’s risk of ill effects. However, we already have data that shows that the accumulation of slow rates of cosmic ray radiation received during long duration spaceflight is not a show stopper for human Mars exploration. GCR dose rates in low Earth orbit are about half those in interplanetary space. Thus there are half a dozen cosmonauts and astronauts who have already received Mars mission equivalent GCR doses (Avdeyev, Polyakov, Solovyov, Krikalyov, Foale, Walz, Lucid) during extended space missions without any radiological casualties. Furthermore, since the International Space Station (ISS) is continually manned, while Mars missions are only in space about 40 percent of their mission time, the total GCR dose (measured in person-rems) that the ISS program crews will receive over the next ten years of planned operations is about the same as would be received by a series of five crews of five people each if they were launched to the Red Planet every other year over the same period. Thus, in fact the ISS program has already accepted the same level of GCR risk for its crews as would be faced by an ongoing human Mars exploration program.
> Galactic cosmic radiation is not a show stopper for human Mars exploration, and should not be used as an excuse for delay. The space program costs many billions of dollars, which are spent at a real cost to meeting human needs elsewhere. That fact imposes a moral obligation on the program to move forward as quickly and efficiently as possible. It is understandable that radiation researchers should want to justify their funding. But they should not spread misinformation to promote themselves at such extraordinary expense to the public.
> Robert Zubrin has a doctorate in Nuclear Engineering from the University of Washington.
> For more details about the Mars Society, please visit: www.marssociety.org <http://www.marssociety.org/>.
> YouTube <applewebdata://08ADE013-DB4F-4FC2-8F00-32D3020F378C>
> <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage.com/track/click?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=4a694a6e41&e=b79b1e1ff5> Share <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage2.com/track/click?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=7592aafbca&e=b79b1e1ff5>
> <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage2.com/track/click?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=e227c29187&e=b79b1e1ff5> Tweet <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage.com/track/click?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=01dee0c0cf&e=b79b1e1ff5>
> The Mars Society
> 11111 West 8th Avenue, unit A
> Lakewood, CO 80215 U.S.A.
> www.marssociety.org <http://www.marssociety.org/> @TheMarsSociety
> Copyright (c) 2015 The Mars Society
> All rights reserved.
> This email was sent to david.hunter at huntergeophysics.com <mailto:david.hunter at huntergeophysics.com>
> why did I get this? <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage1.com/about?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=e219049061&e=b79b1e1ff5&c=f536e4039f> unsubscribe from this list <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage.com/unsubscribe?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=e219049061&e=b79b1e1ff5&c=f536e4039f> update subscription preferences <http://marssociety.us7.list-manage.com/profile?u=66acde49870b0e6bc3a161cc0&id=e219049061&e=b79b1e1ff5>
> The Mars Society, Inc. · 11111 W 8th Ave, Suite A · Lakewood, CO 80215
> · USA
You are currently subscribed to the RadSafe mailing list
Before posting a message to RadSafe be sure to have read and understood the RadSafe rules. These can be found at: http://health.phys.iit.edu/radsaferules.html
For information on how to subscribe or unsubscribe and other settings visit: http://health.phys.iit.edu
More information about the RadSafe