[ RadSafe ] Radiation in San Fran's water
James Salsman
james at bovik.org
Sat Apr 23 18:18:41 CEST 2005
Barbara Hamrick wrote:
>... Just FYI - life is 100% fatal.
As a resident of California, knowing that my state employs
professionals capable of such profound insight makes me want
to phone their entire chain of command first thing Monday
morning so that I can share the details of the entire extent
of my admiration for them.
>> Carl Sagan, on page 322 of “Cosmos,” explains that “Rongalup
>> residents ended up with strontium concentrated in their bones,
>> and radioactive iodine concentrated in their thyroids. Two
>> thirds of the children, and one third of the adults later
>> developed thyroid abnormalities, growth retardation or
>> malignant tumors.”
>
> No offense to Dr. Sagan, and maybe this is substantiated
> somewhere, but I'd really be interested in seeing a peer-reviewed
> study of this population, rather than hearing anecdotal comments
> on it, which have little scientific weight.
Then perhaps you should search the peer-reviewed medical
literature instead of newspaper clippings: Health Phys. 1997
Oct;73(4):651-62, Health Phys. 1997 Dec;73(6):962, Health Phys.
1997 Jul;73(1):190-8, Health Phys. 1996 Oct;71(4):438-56,
World J Surg. 1992 Jan-Feb;16(1):126-40, JAMA 1982 Mar
19;247(11):1571-5, etc.
"There were twenty-one children on Rongelap Island who were
under the age of ten at the time of the Bravo test. Nineteen
of those twenty-one have since had their thyroids removed."
-- Jonathan Weisgall, attorney for Bikini Islanders, 2000
>> Most strontium 90 decays in 96 years and cesium 137 in 100 years.
>
> Technically, they both have a half-life of about 30 years, so
> this statement alone calls into serious question any other
> comments made in the same document.
The fact that my health has been entrusted to a so-called
professional suggesting that 90% is not "most" makes me think
that waiting until Monday morning could be a serious error of
judgment on my part.
Sincerely,
James Salsman
More information about the radsafe
mailing list