More on Sub K-19

["Ted Rockwell" <tedrock@CPCUG.ORG>]

Friends:



For those interested in the sub K-19 and her nuclear accident, here is an

additional bit from Pravda.  ("Pravda" means "truth" in Russian, and

"Izvestia" means "news."  These are major newspapers in Moscow.  It used to

be said that there is no truth in Pravda and no news in Izvestia, but things

are different now, and these paper often print stories that would have been

unthinkable a few years ago.  I have no information as to the reliability of

this story, however.)



Ted Rockwell



17:05 2002-12-11, Pravda

K-19 Submarine Tragedy Caused by Lack of Knowledge



The Soviet Union fixed its nuclear reactors at the price of human lives



The presentation of the American blockbuster "K-19. The Widowmaker" is over.

The movie starring Harrison Ford has been shown in cinemas across Russia. It

seems that almost all Russian and Soviet submariners accept the certain

rough edges of its plot. The word "almost" is an important in this sentence.

The controversy continues.



The Russian website Shipbuilding.Ru handed over a unique article to

PRAVDA.Ru for publication yesterday. The article was accompanied with the

following letter: "You can place this article on your site. The story was

written by Alexander Pokrovsky. He is the author of two novels "Shoot" and

"Shoot 2." After the premier of the movie K-19, we asked him to write an

article about this submarine. Here is what he presented us with."



Russian submariners nicknamed this submarine "Hiroshima." We would like to

add here that Alexander Pokrovsky is a former chief of the nuclear submarine

chemical service.



"I was asked to tell the story of the K-19 submarine. My story is not going

to be boring. In my work, I used personal notes of Mr. Zateyev, the first

commander of K-19.



"The K-19 is referred to the first generation of nuclear cruisers. They

started being used in 1961. A nuclear submarine of that time could stay at

sea for only 30 days due to technical reasons. As a matter of fact,

submarines could travel for only ten to fifteen days due to poor

steam-generation units. Those units would always leak. The reactors' lids

were not good either. The second generation of nuclear submarines were

equipped with better steam-generators and better reactors. They were made of

special carbonaceous steel, which finally put an end to all those leaks.



Numerous breakdowns made those first generation reactors stronger, so to

speak. Practice made it possible for a first generation nuclear sub to

travel for 30, 40, 45 days. It became possible later. Back in those years,

radiation was a mystery. Both submariners and even academicians knew little

about it. Academician Alexandrov, for instance, did not wish to put a safety

costume on, when he arrived to examine K-19 after the breakdown. He did not

want to take a radiation monitor along: "Take this bullshit away," he said

to the chemists who were on radiation guard near the submarine. The K-19 was

polluted with a high level of radiation. There was a lot of radioactive dirt

on the captain's keys; the monitor's scale was not enough to measure the

radiation level.



"Academician Alexandrov did not watch his language when he talked about

radiation and the affect that it has on people. You can imagine what the

submariners thought about it, taking into consideration the fact that

radiation is not visible and its impact on the human body might show later.

Submariners sometimes used distant sites of their first generation

submarines for smoking, because there was no special smoking room on those

subs. Some of them even slept there at times, since it was too stuffy in

cabins. A reactor compartment always had fresh air in, because it was

ionized with radiation. It often happened that an officer, who preferred to

sleep in a reactor compartment, would lose his eyesight, but it would happen

only later. We were taught that there could be two attitudes to radiation:

either fear, or total ignorance.



"There were many stories told about the K-19 submarine. The description of

the breakdown that happened on board the sub was different than what captain

Zateyev wrote in his notes. Despite my great respect of this person, I have

to say that all commanders of those years were not really good with reactor

equipment. There were dialogues like this: "What kind of neutrons are there

in our reactor?" - "Slow ones!" - "Start using fast ones now!" This is not a

joke. Such commands were common for the 1960s. People did not know a lot

about the subject at that time. Practice was obtained gradually, from

victims and breakdowns.



"The K-19 had the following compartments: the first one - the torpedo

compartment, the second one was the storage battery, the third one was the

central post, the fourth was the missile compartment, the fifth was the

diesel compartment, the sixth was the reactor compartment, the seventh was

the turbine compartment, the eighth was the electrotechnological

compartment, the ninth was the compartment of emergency equipment, and the

tenth was the dwelling compartment.



"The breakdown happened in the reactor compartment on the 16th day at sea.

It was reported to the commander that the pressure in the reactor dropped to

zero. The trouble was caused with a leak of a pulse pipe in the reactor

compartment. The pulse pipe was connected to a pressure gauge in the pump

compartment. The pressure gauge indicated the pressure in the first circuit,

where the pulse pipe was.



"People started panicking. Everyone was running around without an idea of

what to do. It did not occur to anyone that the pumps still worked, that the

temperature in the first circuit did not change drastically. It was decided

to pump water through the cooling system of the electric engine. The

submariners were sure that there was no pressure at all in the first

circuit. They thought it wrong. An explosion happened. Water turned into

steam immediately, and the blast wave damaged a part of the deck-cabin. The

people who were exposed to steam were also exposed to radiation. In

addition, the steam burnt their skin.



"This was the way the breakdown was described during numerous analyses.

Academician Alexandrov saved the crew of the submarine from the criminal

persecution. Soviet officials wanted to find the guilty people and to punish

them. That was their major goal.





"People say that there was a leak of uranium, which was then accumulated on

the bottom of the reactor. I am drawn to believe this version. There was no

water in the reactor, and the temperature was too high. Pumping water might

result in an explosion that would damage the reactor's lid.



"The details of the breakdown are not relevant at the moment, I think. The

navy amended its nuclear reactors at the price of human lives. A submarine

is a very complicated mechanism, and people's deaths helped to find out how

it works. The K-19's troubles were not over after that breakdown. Its

reactor was removed and then substituted with another one. The submarine was

repaired and it went to sea again. Later, it ran into a NATO submarine

(without any victims). There was also a large fire on board the K-19. The

fire destroyed two compartments (the eighth and the ninth), and 28 people

died. After the fire was extinguished, the submarine surfaced, and it was

pulled to the base. When at the base, there were ten living people found in

the tenth compartment of the submarine. They were waiting to be rescued for

many days and nights. This is all I know about the long-suffering K-19

submarine of the Northern Navy."



************************************************************************

You are currently subscribed to the Radsafe mailing list. To unsubscribe,

send an e-mail to Majordomo@list.vanderbilt.edu  Put the text "unsubscribe

radsafe" (no quote marks) in the body of the e-mail, with no subject line.

You can view the Radsafe archives at http://www.vanderbilt.edu/radsafe/